Red flags to screen for vertebral fracture in patients presenting with low back pain. Screening for red flags in individuals with low back pain lbp has been a historical hallmark of musculoskeletal management. Sep 19, 2017 if any of the red flag findings are identified, senior doctor input must be sought urgently to guide patient management and analgesia should be prescribed see acute low back pain treatment. Randomised trial of effect of alendronate on risk of fracture in women with existing vertebral fractures. Red flags for the early detection of spinal infection in back pain patients mohamed yusuf1, laura finucane2 and james selfe1 abstract background. Red flag screening is endorsed by most lbp clinical practice guidelines, despite a lack of support for their diagnostic capacity. The way it is put together is designed for movement. Red flags of ominous etiology are identified in table 1 and include. Red flags to screen for malignancy and fracture in patients with low back pain. Early identification and management of psychological risk. Red flags presented in current low back pain guidelines. We share four major reasons why red flag screening is not consistent with best practice in lbp management. Red flags for serious etiologies of acute low back pain. Red flags for potential serious conditions in patients.
A popular idea that didnt work and should be removed from guidelines nearly all guidelines on low back pain have stressed the importance of red flag signspositive answers to key questions. The absence of red flag findings does not always exclude serious pathology. This is possibly the largest singlecenter study on the utility of red flags in low back pain, with nearly 10,000 patients completing a standardized. Martin underwood, rachelle buchbinder created date. Feb 15, 2012 red flags are common in patients with acute low back pain and do not necessarily indicate serious pathology. The article reinforces the idea that clusters of alerting features red flags are more predictive of a serious spinal pathology than individual features. Should we still use red flags in the diagnosis of low back. The concept of yellow flags sparked much attention and debate and was adopted in some guidelines on the early. The evaluation for low back pain should include a complete, focused medical history looking for red flags, which include, but are not limited to. Red flags nred flags are a list of prognostic variables for serious pathology n csp guidelines 2007. Red flags for potential serious conditions in patients with. There is limited evidence or guidance on how red flags should be used in practice. Request pdf red flags presented in current low back pain guidelines.
Red flags for the early detection of spinal infection in back. Low back pain is the leading cause of years lived with disability and the second most common reason for a physician visit. The recommendation on admission or referral if there are red flag sign and symptoms is based on expert opinion in the guideline for the evidenceinformed primary care management of low back pain published by a canadian guideline group toward optimized practice, 2015, a further guideline on adult acute and subacute low back pain published by. Red flags low back pain indicate possible serious pathology indicate the need for further investigation and, possibly, specialist referral. Red flags in low back pain northwest association of. Radiological studies are not required for acute low. Red flag indicators of serious conditions do not presume that, in all cases, low back pain is mechanical in origin. Low back pain look for the red flag signs south sudan. Boden, md investigation performed at emory university, atlanta, georgia.
Red flags are signs and symptoms that are possible indicators of serious spinal pathology. Red flags for low back pain are not always really red. Keep a high index of suspicion in high risk patients or where more than one red flag is present. A wide variety of red flags was presented in guidelines for low back pain, with a lack of consensus between guidelines for which red flags to endorse. Red flags low back pain agency for clinical innovation. Types of low back pain there are three broad types.
Resting for more than a couple of days after low back pain. The patients completed a questionnaire that included several red flag questions during their first physician visit. Evidenceinformed primary care management of a summary. Back pain is one of the most common reasons for visits to the emergency department. Possible tumourinfection age 50 years history of cancer constitutional. Presence of red flags in acute low back pain suggests the need for further. Possible fracture major trauma minor trauma in elderly or osteoporotic patient. The red flags of back pain are important historical and physical features that point to potentially dangerous conditions. Positive red flags are typically indications for imaging. Explain that his leg pain is due to irritation of the nerve roots and.
Back imaging is associated with radiation exposure, which can increase the risk for cancer in the case of lumbar radiography and ct chou r, qaseem a, owens dk, et al. Diagnosis and treatment of acute low back pain american. All guidelines focused on the management of patients with low back pain in a primary care or multidisciplinary care setting. It also includes lower extremity pain that results from a low back disorder sciaticaradiating low back pain, whether there is trunk pain or not. Low back pain low back pain is very common and what you do in the early stages is important. Low back pain lbp is posterior trunk pain between the ribcage and the gluteal folds. Show him a diagram or model of the lumbar spine indicating the vertebrae, discs, and nerve roots. Sciatica is radiating, lower extremity pain and may not be associated with back pain. Patients with nonspecific back pain for less than 6 weeks with no red flags do not need imaging and can be discharged with analgesics and outpatient followup. Diagnosis and treatment of acute low back pain aafp. Red flags for potential serious conditions in patients with low back problems red flags for the low back region condition red flag data obtained during interviewhistory red flag data obtained during physical exam back related tumor1,2 age over 50 history of cancer unexplained weight loss failure of conservative therapy. We searched databases, the world wide web and contacted experts aiming to find the multidisciplinary clinical guideline in low back pain in primary care, and selected the most recent one per. Such symptoms and signs should alert the practitioner to a serious health problem and thus guide selection of investigations, particularly appropriate imaging of the lumbar spine. The guide to assessing psychosocial yellow flags in acute low back pain provides an overview of risk factors for longterm disability and work loss, and an outline of methods to assess these.
Although rare representing less than 1% of acute presentations of back pain. Low back red flag check lists have poor test specificity. Low back pain has a high prevalence and morbidity, and is a source of substantial healthcare spending. Back pain with bladder bowel dysfunction or leg weakness. Low back pain 2 key messages medication table do a full clinical assessment. Advice for highvalue health care from the american college of physicians. A popular idea that didnt work and should be removed from guidelines nearly all guidelines on low back pain have stressed the importance of red flag signspositive answers to. Numerous published guidelines support the use of socalled red flag questions to screen for serious pathology in patients with low back pain.
These red flags were defined in a set of guidelines on acute low back pain published by the agency for health care policy and. Many patients with low back pain have at least one red flag 80% evaluate red flags in the context of the clinical presentation as a whole. Red flags are warning signs that suggest that physician referral may be warranted. Risk factors for cancer if all three of these risk factors for cancer are absent, studies suggest that cancer can be ruled out with 100% sensitivity. Identification of a red flag warrants close attention and further diagnostic testing. Nonspecific low back pain sciatica nerve root pain serious spinal pathology red flags nonspecific low back pain this is the most common type of back pain 95 people in 100. Red flags are symptoms or signs that suggest a patients low back pain lbp may be due to a serious pathology as opposed to the more common tissue injuries. Red flags for serious disease causing low back pain. A differential diagnosis section supports the diagnostic triage of low back pain, noting that nonspecific low back pain implies no known pathoanatomical cause. Red flags are features on history suggestive of serious underlying disorders that may present as back pain. Red flags for the early detection of spinal infection in. Red flags for low back pain are not always really red cor kinetic. Many patients with low back pain have at least one red flag 80%. However, this may not always be true and you should know that there are some red flags that should make you go see a doctor as soon as possible.
Red flags for low back pain are not always really red a prospective evaluation of the clinical utility of commonly used screening questions for low back pain ajay premkumar, md, mph, william godfrey, bs, michael b. This paper examines the effectiveness of red flag questions as a screening tool for patients presenting with low back pain to a multidisciplinary academic spine. Seven of the 11 red flag items were documented over 98% of the time. Jun 06, 20 the red flags of back pain are important historical and physical features that point to potentially dangerous conditions. For the past week he has had an exacerbation of his symptoms and intermittent pain radiating down his right leg. Documentation of red flags by physical therapists for. This is consistent with the findings of verhagen et al.
Keep a high index of suspicion in high risk patients. Evidence for the accuracy of recommended red flags was lacking. An exact diagnosis is often not possible, nor needed. A wide variety of red flags was presented in guidelines for low back pain. Downloaded from low back pain look for the red flag signs. Similarly, patients presenting with radiculopathy at l4l5 or l5s1 most often have disc herniation and often do not require emergent imaging either lin 2014. Consequently, there is a lack of evidence supporting the accuracy of using red flags to identify serious pathologies, which are typically of low prev alence.
Kendall and colleagues1 coined the term yellow flags to encompass psychological risk factors and social and environmental risk factors for prolonged disability and failure to return to work as a consequence of musculoskeletal symptoms. Acute low back pain assessment emergency care institute. The spine is one of the strongest parts of your body. The purpose of this study was to identify and descriptively compare the red flags endorsed in guidelines for the detection of serious pathology in patients presenting with low back pain to primary care. Red flags are common in patients with acute low back pain and do not necessarily indicate serious pathology.
Low back pain is so common that most of the people assume that it is always related to a muscle strain or to a joint strain. Overview of recommendations on red flag screening in low back pain guidelines. Due to the lack of robust evidence for many red flags their use has been questioned. Overall, we found 46 discrete red flags related to the four. It is not possible to diagnose the exact cause of in the majority of people suffering from back pain. Low back pain murtaghs general practice, 7e murtagh. Everyone will experience back pain at some point in their lives having a solid approach to ruling out life threatening diagnoses is critical and will come in handy on your very next emergency shift. It is surrounded by strong muscles and ligaments which support and protect the spine. A 40 year old man presents with a two year history of chronic low back pain. There are several socalled red flag or precautionary pointers to a serious underlying cause of back pain see table 38. This episode of crackcast covers rosens chapter 54, back pain. Evaluate red flags in the context of the clinical presentation as a whole. Mar 07, 2018 a prospective evaluation of the clinical utility of commonly used screening questions for low back pain, provides further insight into the diagnostic accuracy of red flags in low back pain. Initial imaging with mri, which is the preferred study, or ct is only recommended for patients 2with red flags for serious or rapidly progressive disease table 2 5,6 or radicular symptoms that do not spon.
549 228 1102 1208 1498 1022 634 1151 1065 1058 1241 1364 1142 1150 950 995 1149 805 92 597 499 762 930 1211 189 1353 970 426 973 1425 938 330 1442 164 958 102 169